Menu Close

Author: Jenn Manes

New Federal Judge Now Overseeing Caneel Case

The future of Caneel Bay Resort remains uncertain.

And the drama continues over at Caneel Bay

Robert A. Malloy, the federal judge who has been presiding over the federal Caneel Bay case that was filed in June 2022, has been replaced. Cheryl Ann Krause, a federal judge on the United States Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit, replaced Judge Malloy without explanation late last month. The case will decide whether the National Park Service will retain ownership of the 150-acre parcel or if a private equity firm will instead.

What makes this move odd is that it comes with zero explanation as to why a judge who is physically outside of the Territory would be assigned to this case or why Judge Malloy was replaced. Judge Krause is based in Pennsylvania. The docket simply stated:

ORDER (RAM) REASSIGNING CASE. This case is reassigned to the Honorable Cheryl Ann Krause for all further proceedings. Chief Judge Robert A. Molloy is no longer assigned to this case.

The United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit serves the areas of Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, and the US Virgin Islands, so we clearly fall under its jurisdiction. I just find it odd that Judge Krause will travel to the island to hear this case. It is common for judges to get reassigned to cases, but there is usually a clear explanation for it.

I reached out to a repeat tour guest Monday, who happens to serve as a state judge in Georgia, and asked her thoughts on the matter.

“I would not call it common, but it is not unusual, particularly in a smaller jurisdiction,” she told me.

Judge Krause joined the court in 2014 after being nominated by President Barack Obama. According to Alliance for Justice, Judge Krause “has substantial experience litigating complex financial fraud cases.”

“Krause led the prosecution and investigation of a $65 million food stamp fraud conspiracy,” according to Alliance for Justice. “The investigation spanned two years and resulted in more than 60 pleas and convictions, including of several bank officers. It also led to a second wave of prosecutions for an international narcotics money laundering conspiracy, which Krause also handled.”

As you may recall, Judge Malloy postponed the case’s bench trial indefinitely last September, writing “…due to the Court’s calendar and criminal trials taking precedence, the trial in this matter cannot go forward as scheduled.” Perhaps this is why Judge Krause was assigned the case…

An in-person status conference with Judge Krause is scheduled for next Wednesday, January 17th in St. Thomas. Hopefully, we will get more answers then.  In the meantime, you can click this link to get the entire backstory on the debacle that the Caneel Bay Resort has become. 

Looking to take a St. John island tour?

Learn more here –> www.explorestj.com/tour Full & half days available. Rated “Excellent” on TripAdvisor.

Follow Explore STJ on Social Media

–> www.facebook.com/explorestj

–> www.instagram.com/explorestj

 

 

 

Visiting the BVI: Taking the Ferry to Jost

Dalton relaxing in White Bay, Jost van Dyke

Repeat island tour guests invited me to take the ferry to Jost van Dyke with them yesterday, and we had so much fun! It was such an easy process that I thought I would share the details with all of you.

Let’s start with logistics. Jost van Dyke is an island in the British Virgin Islands. It takes about 30 minutes to get there by boat. Because it is another country, you need a passport to visit and, upon arrival, you will need to clear through customs and immigration. Jost has numerous popular beach bars, including Soggy Dollar Bar and Foxy’s, as well as beautiful white sandy beaches. It is a great place to spend the day.

There are several ways to get to Jost. You can rent a private boat (Dulce Vita Sails, Flyaway Charters, Island Roots Boat Charters, Palm Tree Charters, or Sunshine Daydream Boat Charters are all great!), or you can hop on a group trip. If you simply want to go to Jost and back, the ferry is an easy alternative.

Inter Island Boat Services offers ferry service between Cruz Bay and Jost van Dyke every Sunday, Tuesday, and Friday. The cost is $120 for adults and $100 for children ages three to 11. Children two and under are free. There is an additional $30 per person for customs that you pay directly to the British Virgin Islands government upon arrival. Children five and under are exempt from this fee.

The ferry leaves at 8 a.m. They ask that you arrive 45 minutes early, which is rough for this island girl. We arrived at 7:40 a.m., and we were some of the last passengers on the boat. The ferry left promptly at 8 a.m., and we pulled into Great Harbour, Jost van Dyke at 8:30 a.m.

The ferry to Jost leaves from the creek in Cruz Bay.
The ferry to Jost is the same ferry that runs between Cruz Bay and Crown Bay.

We waited in line for about 15 minutes before we handed our passports over to get stamped at the first window. We then paid $10 each at the next window. After that, we went outside and then back inside to a separate section of the building where we had to pay an additional $20 departure tax. We were told to keep the stamped receipt, which we needed to show when we left at the end of the day. By 8:53 a.m., we were walking down the street to Tipsy Shark for breakfast.

We pulled into Jost around 8:30 a.m.
It took about 10 minutes to walk over to the restaurants.
Dalton was mad at us yesterday morning when he didn’t wake up to snow…

Mike, Dalton, and I sat for breakfast and enjoyed the view for about an hour before taking a taxi over to White Bay, home of Soggy Dollar Bar. We had a great breakfast at Tipsy Shark, and it was reasonably priced too. I would definitely go back.

The taxi from Great Harbour (where Foxy’s, Ali Baba’s, and Corsair’s are located, among other great spots) to White Bay (Soggy Dollar, Gertrude’s, and Hendo’s are a few spots here) took about five or so minutes. The cost for the three of us was $20.

Tipsy Shark restaurant at Great Harbour
The view from Tipsy Shark
They also have tables on the beach.
The taxi from Great Harbour to White Bay took less than 10 minutes.

The taxi dropped us off at Soggy Dollar Bar at 10:15 a.m. and we stayed there until 3:30 p.m. It was the perfect amount of time. Dalton made a ton of new friends throughout the day, so he was busy playing in the water and building sandcastles while Mike and I visited with friends and indulged in a cocktail or two. I was excited to see that Soggy Dollar now offers blended drinks. I tried the Buskwacker (two actually!), and they were delicious!

We made it to White Bay!
Relaxing on White Bay
Dalton found a classmate & jumped off their boat a few times!
Bushwacker on the beach… yes, please!

A taxi was waiting for us when it was time to head back to Great Harbour to catch the ferry back home. It left promptly at 4 p.m. and we were in line at US Customs & Immigration at 4:30 p.m. We were at the end of the line, so clearing in took about 15 minutes. We handed the officer our passports and were on our way within minutes.

Heading home…
US Customs in Cruz Bay

Taking the ferry is an inexpensive option when you simply want to visit Jost van Dyke, but it in no way can replace the experience of hiring a licensed boat charter company. The ferry was simply a way of getting from A to B. I prefer booking a private charter when looking to get the real British Virgin Islands experience. Regardless of how you get there, I love a good BVI boat trip day. Yesterday felt like a vacation, and that was beyond lovely.

And for those of you who enjoy watching Dalton’s adventures, you can follow him on Instagram now at www.instagram.com/daltonsislandlife.

Have a great day everyone!

Looking to take a St. John island tour?

Learn more here –> www.explorestj.com/tour Full & half days available. Rated “Excellent” on TripAdvisor.

Follow Explore STJ on Social Media

–> www.facebook.com/explorestj

–> www.instagram.com/explorestj

Visiting St. John: Restaurant Map & Reservations

Hello everyone, and happy Thursday! I am back on island after a quick vacay to Connecticut to see friends and family for New Year’s Eve (and to escape the crazy holiday crowds here!), and I am happy to report that the island has calmed down a bit. Phew! Since it’s the start of the year, this is a good time to re-share Explore STJ’s restaurant map while providing some information on restaurant reservations. There are also a few new openings and closings to share, as well.

Explore STJ’s Restaurant Map

Explore STJ’s Restaurant Map can be found at www.explorestj.com/restaurantmap. It is a searchable map that shows you the locations of all of our restaurants here on St. John. Check it out below:

New and Recently Closed Restaurants

Shambles has a new Sweet Shack located directly across the street. It has ice cream for the kids and drinks for the adults, in addition to an amazing view from its second floor. I will have more on this for you all next week.

Da Event Lounge is a great new spot in Cruz Bay that not only serves as an event space but it’s also become a hot spot for live local music. I will have more on this soon.

Banana Deck is serving lunch again this season! Yay!

Quiet Mon Pub closed last month. I am not certain what is taking its place at this point.

Salty Mongoose temporarily closed in Coral Bay. The rumor is that they will reopen at the old Pastory Gardens minigolf course near Cruz Bay sometime this winter. Fingers crossed that’s true!

Wine Shop VI remains temporarily closed too as construction continues above it at the Wharfside Hotel.

Restaurant Reservations

If you are planning a trip to St. John and you want to dine at any of the following restaurants, I recommend making a reservation.

  • 1864: Definitely for dinner. Not so much for lunch.
  • Banana Deck: Recommended for dinner.
  • Dave & Jerry’s Steakhouse
  • Extra Virgin Bistro
  • La Tapa
  • Morgan’s Mango
  • Ocean 362
  • Rhumb Lines
  • The Terrace
  • ZoZo’s

That’s it for today, folks. I hope today’s post makes your vacation planning a little easier! Have a great day!

Looking to take a St. John island tour?

Learn more here –> www.explorestj.com/tour Full & half days available. Rated “Excellent” on TripAdvisor.

Follow Explore STJ on Social Media

–> www.facebook.com/explorestj

–> www.instagram.com/explorestj

 

 

St. John Webcams Wednesday!

Hello all! I am currently on a plane back home, so forgive me for not posting a real story today. Please take a few minutes to check out our St. John webcams. Enjoy!

St. John Spice Cam – Overlooking the ferry dock & Cruz Bay

The Beach Bar – Bar Cam

The Beach Bar – Panoramic Beach Cam

The Beach Bar – Stage Cam (This webcam is only online when The Beach Bar has live music.)

The Windmill Bar

Coconut Coast Studios – Overlook Frank Bay toward St. Thomas – Sunset Views & Sound 

Mare Blu villa – Overlooking Rendezvous Bay

Villa Circe – Views of Tortola, Jost Van Dyke, Sir Francis Drake Channel & more

Calichi at Picture Point – 360 degree views!

Coral Bay Views – Located at Coconut Hill cottage, high above Coral Bay

Grande Bay Resort – Overlooking Cruz Bay

Fish Camp – Overlooking Turner Bay, Little St. James & French Cap

Great Expectations villa – Overlooking Hart & Rendezvous bays

Great Expectations – Sunset cam

La Jolla Caribe – Located in Catherineberg, high above Cinnamon Bay – northeast view

La Jolla Caribe – northwest view

Long Bay Beach Villa – St. John’s East End

Lovango Resort & Beach Club

Maho Bay House

Soggy Dollar Bar – Located over in Jost Van Dyke in the British Virgin Islands 

Villa Calypso – Overlooking Klein Bay with views of Ditliff Point

Windsong Villa – Overlooking Fish Bay & beyond

Windswept Point Live – Located on a point between Trunk & Cinnamon bays 

Coconuts villa – Located in Gifft Hill with views toward Pillsbury Sound & St. Thomas 

https://www.weather.vi/webcam.php

Esprit villa – Located on Bordeaux Mountain, above Coral Bay

https://espritstjohn.com/live-webcam/

Sunset Ridge Villas – Located above Cruz Bay with views toward St. Thomas 

http://208.84.193.93:88/popup.html

Driving in St. John: Skinnys to East End

Happy New Year! Let’s start the year off with a relaxing drive from Skinny Legs in Coral Bay along Centerline Road to the East End. The East End is unbelievably green and lush at the moment, and the seas were F-L-A-T when I recorded this video last week. Please take some time to enjoy this little drive around St. John.


Explore STJ would like to welcome our newest advertiser Island Paradise Realtors!

🏝 Island Paradise Realtors 
  • Land for sale: 12-3 Peter Bay
Voted “Best St. John Real Estate Agency & Agent” for 10+ years. 
IslandParadiseRealtors.com 
Email: dianabeamstj@gmail.com
Call: 340-690-4170


2023: The Year in Review

Hello everyone, and happy New Year’s Eve! I cannot believe that today is the last day of 2023! So many great things happened in St. John this year. Here is a little recap of some of the highlights!

We announced the opening of two great new spots in January – The Upstairs Bar & Grill and VI Wine Shop. Both technically opened in December, but thanks to island time, I let you all know about them in January. 🙂 The Upstairs is a great sports bar and the Wine Shop quickly became one of my favorite spots on St. John. I love wine. What can I say?! Sadly, it hasn’t been able to reopen after closing for off-season last August due to ongoing construction at the Wharfside Hotel. Soon come… I hope!

The National Park Service also announced its two options for the future of Caneel Bay Resort. It basically came down to all or nothing – rebuild the hotel and create open spaces or leave it alone essentially. They asked the public for feedback and said they would consider that when making their decision.

We had a pretty amazing thing happen in February. We had a flamboyant of flamingos visit! This is a rare occurrence these days, but a very welcomed one! They stuck around for several months, which made this “bird nerd” super excited!

Sadly we lost a business in February when the Coral Bay Fresh Market abruptly closed its doors. Nothing has reopened in that space since.

Ferry service to St. Thomas got even easier in March when the Charlotte Amalie ferry resumed. There are now three ferries that run between St. John and St. Thomas – Red Hook, Crown Bay, and Charlotte Amalie. A couple of new retail shops opened too. The Little Things opened in Cruz Bay and Pirate’s Cove opened out in Coral Bay. And rounding out the month, Lime Out began a new shuttle service making the trip out for tacos on the water even easier.

Even more businesses opened in April here in St. John. In Cruz Bay, we gained a great new coffee shop – Downtown Sips – as well as Dolphin Grab & Go, which is a quick-serve breakfast and lunch spot. Coral Bay gained a new sweet spot when Dazey Drive-In opened. It’s a great dessert shop that specializes in Hawaiian ice.

There will come as no surprise, but Trunk Bay was named one of the world’s best beaches in May. The Saharan dust arrived for the first time in 2023 in May, and Aqua Bistro closed out in Coral Bay. We also learned that Little St. James and Great St. James, the islands owned by Jeffrey Epstein, had sold to a St. John resident, who plans to open a luxury resort on the smaller of the two islands.

June is such a great month in St. John as the annual Carnival celebration began. This is such an important time of year on St. John as it truly celebrates the island culture, and without that, St. John wouldn’t be the amazing place that it is. We even had an actual carnival in June complete with a ferris wheel and everything. It was absolutely incredible, and I hope it returns in 2024!

St. John honored Emancipation Day on July 4th with a parade, music, and fireworks. It was a beautiful day that featured colorful troupes, music and so much more.

The Oppenheimer movie sparked a new interest in St. John for many, as Robert Oppenheimer lived here after he lost his security clearance. It’s an interesting connection that many people were not aware of. And lastly, in July, the National Park Service announced that it plans to rebuild a hotel on the Caneel Bay property.

August was an amazing month for me because I bought a house! I never imagined I would ever be able to own a home in St. John, but I now own an adorable little property out in Fish Bay. And I could not be happier!

September is a bit of a fog for me, as I was busy playing construction foreman out in Fish Bay. I do know that many of you stepped up to help our teachers at Sprauve School in Cruz Bay clear their supply lists. A big thank you to all who helped!

We quickly learned on October 1st that Caneel Bay would not become part of the National Park as it should have due to a frivolous lawsuit filed by EHI Acquisitions, the former operators of the Caneel Bay Resort. That lawsuit is ongoing, and no progress has been made since.

The island started to fill up in November, but not without some unexpected changes. Quiet Mon Pub announced it was forced to close after 26 years due to an astronomical rent increase. Lime Inn announced some restaurant changes too, and Midway opened a new breakfast and lunch spot on Centerine Road.

And here we are in December. We had our first cruise visit and a lot of superyachts too. The island is extremely busy and parking has been crazy. I escaped the crowds for a bit, and will be celebrating New Year’s Eve in New England with some of my best friends. But don’t worry, I have friends who are planning to celebrate in Cruz Bay tonight, so I should have some pics and videos to share with all of you tomorrow.

I want to end this by saying that I truly appreciate every one of you. Thank you for taking the time to read what I write every day. ExploreSTJ.com has been viewed well over a million times this year, which is absolutely incredible. And to those of you who took an island tour with me in 2023, I appreciate you all too. You all are helping me live my dream, and I cannot thank you enough.

Happy New Year everyone. xoxo

Looking to take a St. John island tour?

Learn more here –> www.explorestj.com/tour Full & half days available. Rated “Excellent” on TripAdvisor.

Follow Explore STJ on Social Media

–> www.facebook.com/explorestj

–> www.instagram.com/explorestj